Oneblock - Either move pinata back to pvp 100% of the time, or make something else for pvp...

LionClient

Known Member
Nov 11, 2021
210
10
18
Noord-Brabant


Gamemode
Oneblock

Title Either move pinata back to pvp 100% of the time, or make something else for pvp...

Description of suggestion
So, when pinata spawns its now a 50/50 to spawn in either pvp or mobfarm. Which sounds like a good system, if you don't look at the boss bar and scoreboard both saying a different area... But, cool, pinata now spawns in mobfarm, but when it does spawn in mobfarm pvp is dead... pvp is only active when the pinata is there, so moving it to mobfarm basically kills pvp... So id say either move it back to pvp 100% of the time, OR make a different event especially for pvp (Like maybe a KOTH event that spawns in pvp arena), that rewards the one on top with either money or items (i'd recommend items because money economy is very unstable). And also, a argument for moving the pinata to mobfarm i saw was "Don't enforce pvp on a not pvp server", but this is just plain incorrect... Pvp has been a large part of foxcraft for a while, there's a pvp arena, there are custom (mostly pvp related) enchants, there are bounties, etc... So i'd recommend making a custom event for pvp.

Possible side effects of suggestion
Good: it will revive pvp
Bad: New players wil indeed not be able to get much of the rewards from pinata, but thats why a custom event for pvp is the best option
 
I think the 50/50 is a great way for everyone to enjoy pinata. I understand it may be disappointing depending where it gets placed but It's great for players that have lower armor or are just starting the game to get pinata keys, meanwhile 50% of the time still keeping pvpers happy as it gets put in their area half of the time. It's a good way for both the people who don't want to get killed in pvp and the people who want to actually fight in pvp to both get what they want. I understand where you're coming from and an extra pvp event would be cool but I think 50/50 is nice for pinata! :)

-1 on 50/50 going back to 100% pvp, +1 on possible new pvp event for pvp revival.
 
I tihnk the 50/50 is a great idea so everyone, for every type of game play, has a chance.

-1

+1 for adding something NEW for Pvp to revive it.